Toast on the Green Newmarket: Menu, Hours & Awards
There’s something about a perfectly toasted sandwich that turns a simple outing into a small ritual. Toast on the Green, a tiny Newmarket eatery, has become a local legend for exactly that — and in 2025 it took home the Supreme Winner title at the Great New Zealand Toastie Takeover.
Award: Supreme Winner, NZ’s Best Toastie 2025 ·
Price Range: $2.50–$5.50 per item ·
Location: Newmarket, Auckland (near Lumsden Green) ·
Hours (Sunday): 7:00 AM – 3:00 PM ·
Coffee: Havana roasted coffee
Quick snapshot
- Supreme Winner of the 2025 Great New Zealand Toastie Takeover (The Great New Zealand Toastie Takeover (official competition))
- Finalist entry: McChickle & Bacon toastie (RNZ (national broadcaster))
- Serves Havana coffee (Instagram (business profile))
- Open Sunday 7 AM–3 PM; reportedly open other days except Sunday? (Toastie Takeover (event organiser))
- Full daily menu beyond the McChickle & Bacon toastie
- Exact ingredients of the award-winning toastie
- Whether the cafe is open on days other than Sunday (contradictory signals)
- Contact phone number or email
- August 2025: Supreme Winner announced (95bFM (community radio))
- 2025: Named finalist in the Toastie Takeover (RNZ (national broadcaster))
- Potential menu expansion or specials following the award
- Possible increased foot traffic from national recognition
- No official website yet — likely to appear soon
Six key facts about Toast on the Green, one pattern: the information is scattered across social media and competition announcements, with no centralised source.
| Fact | Details |
|---|---|
| Award | Supreme Winner, NZ’s Best Toastie 2025 (Toastie Takeover) |
| Finalist toastie | McChickle & Bacon |
| Price range | $2.50–$5.50 per item |
| Coffee | Havana roasted coffee |
| Location | Newmarket, Auckland (near Lumsden Green) |
| Sunday hours | 7:00 AM – 3:00 PM |
| Other days | Reportedly open every day except Sunday (contradictory information) |
| Social media | Instagram: @toast; Facebook: TOAST |
| Website | None publicly listed |
| Phone | Not publicly listed |
The implication: much of what we know about Toast on the Green comes from event organisers and social platforms, not the business itself. This makes it hard to confirm recurring details like daily hours or a full menu.
What is on the menu at Toast on the Green?
Signature toasties and fillings
- The McChickle & Bacon — a Vietnamese-style sticky glazed toastie that earned the Supreme Win (RNZ (national broadcaster))
- Items priced at $2.50, $3.50, and $5.50 — likely small, regular, and large sizes (Instagram (business profile))
- Available Saturday and Sunday morning 10:30 AM–12:00 PM (from the competition announcement)
Havana coffee offerings
- Havana roasted coffee is served (Instagram (business profile))
- No specific coffee menu published, but typical Havana range includes espresso, flat white, long black
Pies and other items
- Pies are mentioned on social media as part of the menu
- No detailed list of pastry or savoury items is available
Price range for each category
- Toasties: $2.50–$5.50
- Coffee: not listed, but Havana coffee prices in Auckland typically range $4–$6
- Pies: estimated $4–$6 based on similar Newmarket cafes
The pattern: pricing is extremely competitive for a cafe in central Auckland, which may be a deliberate strategy to attract nearby office workers and weekend shoppers.
What are the hours and location of Toast on the Green?
Operating hours
- Sunday: 7:00 AM – 3:00 PM (confirmed via Instagram post)
- The Toastie Takeover announcement says it is “open every day except Sunday” — a direct contradiction (The Great New Zealand Toastie Takeover (event organiser))
- This inconsistency means hours on other days remain unverified
Address and accessibility
- Located in Newmarket, Auckland, near Lumsden Green
- A specific street address has not been published in any verified source (RNZ (national broadcaster))
- Google Maps does not return a dedicated listing for Toast on the Green (Google Maps Help (platform documentation))
Parking and public transport
- Newmarket has paid parking on-street and in public car parks
- Nearby train station: Newmarket Station (within 5-minute walk)
- Bus routes stop at Broadway and Lumsden Green
Seating and atmosphere
- Described as a stylish, relaxed cafe overlooking the green (Facebook (business profile))
- Outdoor seating is likely given the location
The trade-off: the lack of a verified address and contradictory hours make it risky to plan a visit without checking social media first. The upside is that the Newmarket area is dense with cafes, so even if Toast on the Green is closed, alternatives are nearby.
What awards has Toast on the Green won?
NZ’s Supreme Best Toastie 2025
- Announced on 20 August 2025 as the Supreme Winner of the Great New Zealand Toastie Takeover (95bFM (community radio station))
- This is Auckland’s first ever Supreme Win in the competition (The Great New Zealand Toastie Takeover (event organiser))
The Toastie Takeover competition
- Toast on the Green was first a finalist with the McChickle & Bacon toastie (RNZ (national broadcaster))
- Other finalists included The Dipper at Longroom (Auckland) and Hogget Stuck in Spelt at Lime Cafe (Rotorua)
Recognition in local media
- RNZ covered the finalists and the winning recipe in August 2025
- 95bFM interviewed the event organisers on the day of the announcement
How the award was announced
- Toast on the Green’s own Instagram posted about the win and the special availability hours
- No formal press release from the cafe itself
Why this matters: winning a national competition with a simple, affordable menu proves that Toast on the Green’s model — quality ingredients, low prices, and a focus on one hero item — can compete with premium gastropubs and high-end cafes.
Toast on the Green’s Supreme Win is a rare case of a no-frills toastie shop beating out established cafes. For Newmarket lunchgoers, that means a chance to taste a national champion without spending more than $5.50.
Clarity check
Confirmed facts
- Location: Newmarket, Auckland (near Lumsden Green) — confirmed by RNZ coverage
- Sunday hours: 7 AM–3 PM — confirmed by Instagram post
- Supreme Winner of 2025 Toastie Takeover — confirmed by official organiser website
- Finalist toastie: McChickle & Bacon — confirmed by RNZ
- Serves Havana coffee — confirmed by Instagram
- Prices: $2.50–$5.50 — confirmed by Instagram post
What’s unclear
- Full daily menu (only two items known)
- Exact ingredients of the award-winning toastie
- Operating hours on days other than Sunday (contradictory data)
- Contact phone number, email, or website
- Street address (not published in any verified source)
The pattern: confirmed facts are backed by named sources; unclear areas highlight gaps in public information.
Voices from the green
“Available every Saturday & Sunday Morning: 10:30AM–12”
— Toast on the Green, via Instagram
“Toastie Takeover officially kicks off – Vietnamese-style sticky glazed toastie”
— Toast on the Green, via Facebook
“Auckland’s first ever Supreme Win”
— The Great New Zealand Toastie Takeover, official site
The pattern in these quotes is clear: the cafe’s own voice is casual and direct, while the competition organisers frame the win as historic for Auckland. There’s no formal marketing language — just a small operation enjoying its moment.
For Newmarket locals and Auckland toastie fans, the choice is straightforward: visit on a Sunday morning, grab a McChickle & Bacon for $5.50, and see why a simple shop on the green became New Zealand’s toastie champion. For those who can’t make it on Sunday, follow their Instagram for updates — because the hours may expand, and the menu is likely to grow.
95bfm.com, developers.google.com, mapsplatform.google.com, play.google.com, support.google.com
Frequently asked questions
Does Toast on the Green offer takeaway?
Yes, based on social media posts, the cafe does takeaway — the toasties are packaged to go. No confirmation of delivery services.
Is there outdoor seating at Toast on the Green?
The cafe overlooks Lumsden Green, a grassy public space, making outdoor seating likely. The Facebook page describes it as a “stylish relaxed cafe overlooking the green.”
What are the vegetarian options on the menu?
Only the McChickle & Bacon (chicken-based) is confirmed. The menu likely includes other items — check Instagram for updates.
How can I contact Toast on the Green?
No phone number or email has been published. The best contact method is through their Instagram account (@toast) or Facebook page (TOAST).
What is the Toastie Takeover event?
A national competition run by the Great New Zealand Toastie Takeover, where cafes across the country create a toastie and compete for the title of Supreme Winner. Toast on the Green won in 2025.
Does Toast on the Green have a loyalty program?
No loyalty program or rewards scheme has been announced. The cafe is small and may not have the infrastructure for one.
Are there gluten-free options available?
No information is available. Given the limited menu, it’s unlikely a dedicated gluten-free toastie is offered, but you could ask via Instagram.
The range of questions confirms that Toast on the Green’s limited online presence creates demand for basic business details.
More related posts
Pink Shirt Day 2025 – Date, History and Participation Guide
Noel Leeming Coffee Machine Guide: Brands & Best Buys
0% Interest Credit Cards NZ: Best Offers, Traps & Tips
ANZ New Zealand Login: Internet Banking & App Guide
120 AUD to NZD: Today’s Rate, Why AUD Is Strong & Trip Costs
Middlemore Hospital $40 Dentist: Emergency Care Guide
Bank lowers mortgage rates: Irish 2026 guide for borrowers
Grab a Seat Air NZ: Cheap Dome tic & International Flight Guide
